Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in posts
Search in pages

Mandriva Desktop 2011 review

I am reading page: 1 2 3

Physical and Network Security: Disk encryption and boot loader password protection, are two very important security features that you may use to boost the physical security posture of any operating system. And until I can figure out how to encrypt the root partition on Mandriva 2011, or until somebody can show me evidence that it can be done, I just say that support for disk encryption is only partial.

The situation with the boot loader password protection makes my head spin. On August 2, 2011, I wrote a tutorial on how to install Mandriva 2011 on a btrfs file system. For that article, I used a second release ISO installation image, and in the second paragraph, I wrote that “Though the second release candidate still spots some bugs, the installer will not change when the stable edition is released on August 29, 2011.” Was I wrong!

This is the screenshot of the boot loader configuration step I used in that article.
GRUB On Mandriva Desktop 2011 Using Btrfs

And this is one from the same step in the stable release. Can you spot the difference? Do you know why the security feature was removed?
GRUB Settings Mandriva 2011

Still on physical security, even something as simple and as basic as screen-locking (screensaver), is not enabled by default.

With regards to network security, by default, the system is left completely unprotected by a firewall – the firewall is not enabled. As far as I can recall, this is the first Mandriva desktop edition that shipped with the firewall disabled out of the box. Shown below is the main interface of the graphical firewall in its default state.
Mandriva 2011 Firewall

I do not know what informed the decision to disable the firewall out of the box, but whatever it is, the decision is a bad one especially given the fact that a new installation (of Mandriva 2011) has ports 111, 139 and 445 open. The latter two ports, point to a running instance of Samba server. I do not know how easy or difficult it is to compromise a Samba server, but protecting it with a firewall will make any attempt a little bit more difficult.

For the record, the first paragraph of the Network and Internet Connection Management documentation (Chapter 3.1) of Mandriva 2010.2, states that, “By default, your computer is protected by a firewall so as to avoid bad surprises such as intrusions into your system.” If that statement is true for Mandriva 2010.2, it should be true of Mandriva 2011 or any other distribution or operating system.

Final Thoughts: There are so many new and good features on Mandriva 2011, and so many things that are wrong with it too. The good features are not exactly perfect, but they point to a brighter future. What really bothers me are the things that are wrong with it. And that is because they are so minor and so in-plain-sight that I wonder how the QA missed them. Are there any QA’s left in Mandriva?

Considering that this was a major and highly expected release of a major Linux distribution, did anybody in management bother to take it for a spin to see if basic features work? I have visions of Steve Jobs getting involved in every phase of his company’s products development. There does not seem to be a Steve Jobs in Mandriva’s management team.

None of the shortcoming of Mandriva 2011 will stop me from upgrading one of my permanent test systems running Mandriva 2010.2, but my laptop, which I use for serious stuff, on which physical security is just as important as any other feature, will continue running the old system until I figure out how to configure disk encryption when installing my favorite Linux distribution. If you know how, let me know.

Resources: DVD-sized ISO installation images for 32- and 64-bit platforms may be downloaded from here, and the Release Notes are here. Support questions may be posted here and on Questions and Answers.

Screenshots: View more more screenshots from test installations of Mandriva 2011.

A login screen of Mandriva Desktop 2011. Keep in mind that this is not the default login screen, but a custom one on one of my test machines. Guest account and user management on Mandriva 2011 gives step-by-step instructions on how to make one for your system.
Mandriva 2011 Custom Login Screen

Applications in the System administrations section of the ROSA Launcher or SimpleWelcome.
System Apps ROSA Launcher

TimeFrame tab of the ROSA Launcher or SimpleWelcome. By default, it is not functional. Nepomuk has to be enabled first. See how to customize Mandriva 2011 on how to enable it.
Mandriva 2011 TimeFrame

The main view of the KDE Plasma Netbook interface. Note that the Rocketbar has been replaced with the traditional KDE panel on the Desktop interface. That is why the Rocketbar is not visible at the bottom of the interface.
Mandriva 2011 KDE Plasma Netbook

Installed Internet applications viewed from the KDE Plasma Netbook interface.
Internet Apps on Mandriva 2011

Parental Control utility of the Mandriva Control Center. Squid and Dansguardian are used to implement the parental control feature.
Mandriva 2011 Parental Control

I am reading page: 1 2 3

Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in posts
Search in pages
Digital Ocean SSD VPS Cloud Server droplets

Digital Ocean is a VPS/Cloud hosting provider. For just $5 per month, you can get yourself a Cloud server with 512 MB of RAM, 20 GB super-fast SSD, free snapshots, plus backups for a minimal fee. All via a simple graphical interface.

And by signing up with this referral link, you can help support this website.

If you are reading this, your ad could also be occupying this space. Contact us to make it happen.

If commenting on this article is closed, please post your comments at forum.linuxbsdos.com.

17 Comments

  1. Linux comamnds says:

    Superb review. Clear to the point.

  2. Luca says:

    I have to add (look at n. 1 post) that I installed Mandriva 2011, because I encountered some problems with Mageia (random freezes on boot).
    Mandriva is running very good. No problems so far.
    The desktop is BEAUTIFUL, very polished and elegant! I got rid of Rosa panel, installed a standard panel and now I have an absolutely typical KDE desktop (with very nice wallpaper and widgets).
    I added the new Restricted repository and installed all the required codecs and multimedia stuff in a moment!
    Clementine and VLC work very well: I can play everything from mp3 to DVD (after installing libdvdcss2 from the Restricted repository).
    Installing the proprietary Nvidia driver was a breeze!
    The control center is awesome!
    My sincere advice is to try it!

  3. Luca says:

    Very professional review.
    I’ve tried Mandriva on live cd, but then I prefered to install Mageia on hard disk, because I liked a more traditional KDE desktop.
    In my case, Mageia has a better hardware recognition and, in my opinion, is more polished and accurate.
    I believe that Mageia 2 will rock.
    Anyhow, I’m also interested in the future development of Mandriva …

  4. Andreas says:

    “The problem with it, as with Ubuntu’s Software Center and Linux Mint’s Software Manager, is that you cannot queue multiple applications for installation.”

    You can do that, just have to be quick about it so the authorization wont time out before adding the next app.

    • finid says:

      That proves my point. You cannot queue multiple applications for installation in Ubuntu’s Software Center and Linux Mint’s Software Manager.

      • Andreas says:

        Well, if you add them quick they are are put on hold so in the practical sense you still can. But if ticking boxes for the same outcome is the definition then there is that after all. Potato, tomato. ;)

  5. nikesh says:

    I never tried mandriva before but looking at the screenshot I think I should try mandriva now after seeing ubuntu changed to unity.

  6. Keith Bowes says:

    1. RPM originally stood for Redhat Package Manager.
    2. The command line rocks!
    3. I don’t consciously use encryption, so I don’t know (plus, I’m using Mageia 1 instead of Mandriva 2011; I might upgrade to Mandriva 2012, but the Mageia 1 packages are newer than Mandriva 2011’s, so I don’t think downgrading is a good idea).

  7. John says:

    A interesting review. But I must say I prefeer Mageia now instead of Mandriva. Rosa panel, Unity and Gnome 3 are nothing for me yet.
    I am the “old school” in computer look. But who knows, maybe I will try with it someday again.

  8. darkduck says:

    Very nice review, as always on this site. Much more comprehensive and detailed compared to mine (http://linuxblog.darkduck.com/2011/08/mandriva-2011.html)

  9. Stiz says:

    Awesome review. I find the issues you raised about security very interesting. I don’t thing any reasonable person will cripple disk encryption, remove the security features of the boot loader, and disable the firewall. What’s the point?

    I think I smell sabotage. Considering that Mandriva has been bleeding employees, I think a disgruntled developer, must have done something nasty.

    This is a guess, but what other explanation could there be?

Leave a Comment